Before you buy a $40 ticket, it helps to know what kind of night you're buying. Here's an honest review of every major speed dating company: how each format works, what it costs, and who it actually fits.
We write city singles guides for a living, which means we track these organizers' calendars, venues, and formats across multiple cities. These reviews describe what each company actually runs and who it fits. No organizer paid to be here, and none of these are affiliate links.
Format: the hostless one. There's no emcee with a bell: the event runs from your phone, which tells you when each round starts and who to find. Rounds are long by industry standards (around ten minutes instead of four), with breaks between and a conversation prompt each round. Events are small and balanced (typically seven men and seven women, or eight participants at the queer events), matched in advance from a short questionnaire, and results arrive by email the next day.
The honest read: the best format for people who find classic speed dating either exhausting (the conveyor belt) or embarrassing (the host with the microphone). The long rounds are a real conversation, not an interview, and the small matched events mean less randomness. The tradeoffs: fewer people per night than a classic event, and the phone-run format means nobody's in the room to fix a problem live. Fast-growing calendar across major metros (Chicago, Seattle, DC, Denver, Portland, New York among them). Tickets typically $25-40.
Format: the modern one. You fill out a short profile, and during the event an algorithm matches you to your most compatible people in the room; you get a series of 6-8 matched mini-dates instead of rotating through everyone. Events are age-banded and hosted at real bars and lounges. CitySwoon reports that over 95% of attendees leave with at least one mutual match, which tracks with the format: you only sit with people the system already thinks fit.
The honest read: best format for people who hate the conveyor-belt feel of classic speed dating. The tradeoff is trusting the matching: you meet fewer people, chosen for you. Strong presence across big metros (we've tracked its calendars in Dallas and Houston), and it also runs gay speed dating in several cities. Typical tickets $30-50.
Format: volume and variety. Jigsaw bills itself the largest in-person dating event series in the US, and beyond classic speed dating it runs trivia nights, pickleball socials, and other activity formats where meeting people is the point but timed rounds aren't the only mechanism.
The honest read: the pick if a wall of 5-minute interviews sounds exhausting and you'd rather meet people over an activity. Because it's the biggest calendar, event quality varies more night to night than the boutique hosts; read the specific event listing (age band, venue, format) rather than the brand. Typical tickets $25-50.
Format: the classic, and the veteran: 20+ years of timed-round events, strictly age-banded, at restaurants and bars. Mark your card, mutual matches exchanged next day. No gimmicks.
The honest read: the most predictable night on this page, in the good sense. Pre-Dating's age bands are honest and its older bands (40s-50s) fill more reliably than almost anyone's, which makes it a strong pick over 40. If you want exactly what speed dating says on the tin, start here. Typical tickets $25-45.
Format: classic rounds with longer dates: 6-8 minutes, extendable when both people are feeling it, instead of the standard 4-5.
The honest read: the pacing fix. If your speed dating complaint is "every conversation ended mid-sentence," the longer format genuinely helps. Calendar depth varies by city; check yours.
| Company | Format | Best for | Typical ticket |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shuffle | Phone-guided, hostless, long rounds | People who want real conversations without a host or a conveyor belt | $25-40 |
| CitySwoon | Algorithm-matched rounds | People who want curation, not a conveyor belt | $30-50 |
| Jigsaw | Speed dating + activity nights | People who'd rather meet over trivia or pickleball | $25-50 |
| Pre-Dating | Classic timed rounds | The predictable, honest version; strongest 40+ bands | $25-45 |
| The Fun Singles | Longer, extendable rounds | People who hate the 5-minute cutoff | $25-45 |
See singles near you who've already said what they're looking for: free to join and browse.
Browse FreeCity-by-city calendars and venues: our Las Vegas, Dallas, Houston, Phoenix, Atlanta, and Chicago speed dating guides.